Forum for discussing local and world politics and issues. All views are welcomed. Let your opinions be heard on current news and politics.
All standard guidelines apply to this board, No Flaming, No Taunting, No Foul Language,No sexual innuendos,etc..
As politics can be a volatile subject, please consider how you would feel if your comment were directed toward yourself.
Any post deemed to be in violation of guidelines will be deleted or edited without warning or notification. Any continued misbehavior will result in a ban or hidden status, so please play nice!!!
*"Moderators are here for a reason. If a moderator (or Global Moderator or Fencer) requests that a discussion on a certain subject to cease - for whatever reason - please respect these wishes. Failure to do so may result in being hidden, or banned."
List of discussion boards
You are not allowed to post messages to this board. Minimum level of membership required for posting on this board is Brain Pawn.
Imsoaddicted: Some may live in the "better than the Jones age" but not all. And quite frankly, I feel much (from what I've seen/heard) does not extend from that but from pure frustration of the bullies. Getting attention can give rise to some strange and unfortunate disturbances.
Ferris Bueller: Some states! Here at school there is a country wide ban. It is not acceptable. Also the rules (due to incidents) do extend into the realm of the internet, yet such rules were already there in some respects re the ban on internet stalking and other cyber crimes. Such as spreading hate and 'isms to which several people have found themselves before the beak.
gogul: Only because of international pressure on Swiss banks, as the previous conditions to make a claim were at the least.. scandalous. How could death certificates of those killed in the holocaust be produced??
And shamefully, the Swiss, like the UK turned away many Jews trying to flee to a neutral country (or non-Nazi influenced) to escaped being killed.
History is such a depositary of info!! Now you can even access complete records dating back to the 100 years war, thanks to the UK government of the time wanting to know where their money was being spent.
Subject: Re: A world goverment. People who support that idea are dumb.
gogul: illegal drugs or legal drugs?? Legal drugs are worth more then the illegal sort by I would guess quite a factor. And didn't you know.. much of the business in one class has become home grown.
And what about the Swiss banks and a certain organisations gold from WWII.. To which several lawsuits have been raised against Swiss banks
Artful Dodger: So.. the site "Accuracy in Media" is against common decency?? Even against stopping discrimination against women!!
And I must say.. The USA expects extradition to it's country and courts and yet this site does not want fairness in cases where USA people have committed crimes in other countries and hence extradition.
Subject: Re:clearly the US did not fully appreciate the dynamics of Muslims in that part of the world.
Artful Dodger: If they didn't then they really forgot one great deal of a lot of the dynamic history of Iraq. Seeing as it wasn't that far in the past I find that hard to believe. I feel more they just hoped the old internal wars were forgotten about.
Übergeek 바둑이: I find it hard to believe that the 5% was not accounted for. So much 'watching' by various parties that for them not to know does suggest it was known.. or at least highly known to be unlikely.
If not... then despite various 'sightings' of mobile chemical factories (as was claimed) the intel was very, very poor. Stupendously bad in fact for the amount of effort being made. And since a certain C Rice interview over Saddam... I don't recon it was that bad, seeing as she had to give such a performance.
gogul: History is told by survivors of it, so naturally most history has it's ugliness when it comes to power, politics and the ilk. As for the horizon museum pieces.. no. it's a matter of the Taliban out lasting... they know they are no match for us in the battlefield.
And politics in the middle east involves more than the Israeli/Palestinian problem. Religion, cold war and much separatist division. Those who study history would be wise to remember that before Saddam Iraq was torn by civil war, he gave stability to that country, but power and being used by various factions in their 'best' interest power corrupted him and his regime. Billions of dollars fed into his economy so no-one else would have to dirty their hands with blood.
And to why Saddam didn't want inspectors... because the country's army was so weak that he didn't want the Iranians knowing fearing an invasion. I guess the USA knew that seeing as he was such an easy quick victory. Yet all that man power tied up there is a shame as it limits the efforts in Afghanistan.
Czuch: If you are that ignorant about the history in that region.. go away for a year and study. I might then stop having to fill in the gaps of what you know.
.... you could have just googled it and therefore knew before you answered!!
Subject: Re:But lets be fair: many positive things came about because the US stood up to a tyrant.
Artful Dodger: Hopefully yes. Hopefully it'll end the use of tyrants and the like by other country's, as those who would use 'evil' people will realise that it will end up biting you in the butt later.
eg... Iran is so annoyed with the west due it's people being killed by WMD supplied by the west. Now that mess is haunting the world and will for many years.
This is not 'demonising' but being honest of the results of actions that were flawed and irresponsible.
Subject: Re:That would in part require me to betray a trust.
Czuch: So.... are you saying it's ok for the USA to supply people it knows that are 'bad' with the ability to kill their own people and others more efficiently, and knowing before hand that it does kill it's own people and others and will use WMD material that is supplied to them to that extent... it's ok??
And then change it's mind (probably due to embarrassment) then to moan about feeding them, which is a direct result of previous supplying of WMD materials which leads to the necessity of sanctions.
Are you saying that in all cases of the USA (or any other western country) supporting murders and the ilk, it's ok?
If so.. then you'd have to understand why some nations are angry at the USA (and other western nations) for such actions.. wouldn't you.
While the August 18 NYT article added new details about the extent of US military collaboration with Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein during Iraq's 1980-88 war with Iran, it omitted the most outrageous aspect of the scandal: not only did Ronald Reagan's Washington turn a blind-eye to the Hussein regime's repeated use of chemical weapons against Iranian soldiers and Iraq's Kurdish minority, but the US helped Iraq develop its chemical, biological and nuclear weapons programs.
Immediately prior to the US invasion of Iraq, Saddam Hussein delivered a WMD declarations report to the United Nations in an attempt to avert a U.S. invasion. Do you recall that U.S. officials intercepted the report and removed special sections of it, based on claims of “national security”? Well, it turned out that the removed sections involved the delivery of those WMDs by the United States and other Western countries to Saddam Hussein, information that obviously caused U.S. officials a bit of discomfort on the eve of their invasion.
Subject: Re:That would in part require me to betray a trust.
Czuch: Who supplied the WMD's that made him a threat?? The USA.. so if the USA had not given him the material .. which he used against the Iranians, yet that was ok.. he wouldn't have needed monitoring.
Subject: Re:That would in part require me to betray a trust.
Czuch: I'm not contradicting anything.. just trying to understand the reasoning.. and yes the time phrase was years... but you do understand the phrase don't you in the context I meant it??
Please explain who missed that Saddam was nasty and how.. this point I find interesting!!
Artful Dodger: ... In Afghanistan... ok.... But there were none in Iraq. Unless this is part of some long term policy to get Iran and other country's in the area.
Subject: Re:That would in part require me to betray a trust.
Czuch: So the war was good for America in what way? A stable middle east, yet by all rights wouldn't you say that the USA had done little or blocked peace attempts in the past? One minute Saddam is a good guy, been given WMD material,. next he's bad.
And if the USA was tired of monitoring him... why create him in the first place!! You knew he was no good yet the USA gave him WMD material!!
Subject: Re:That would in part require me to betray a trust.
Czuch: Yes.. and in saying so I included quantum math. It is part of the model you know And yes.. you said you presume your models work until they don't...
.. So.. we are in agreement that the model is that there is no model. No way to predict accurately events. Builders know this. Even if they have a plan, they always have to include an uncertainty principle for things that they cannot control.
And it would be helpful if you remember what you said, that democracy was the main reason that we went to war in Iraq... or was it WMD's??
But then saying you have no higher moral ground would negate such reasons. And then the question is.... why were you tired of Saddam?
Subject: Re: ever study chimpanzee tribe behavior? humans are just a higher form
GTCharlie: And human bEiNgS have developed the ability to choose and not be bound by animal fear and flight.. Not to act like animals trapped in a corner lashing out.
Artful Dodger: Only three people.. have you definite proof of that? And what of the other illegal methods of gaining info, which the USA gov and judicial say are illegal to use on their people??
Subject: Re:That would in part require me to betray a trust.
Artful Dodger: Nope.. I answered. And so did Czuch.. and if you agree with Czuch that you needed no moral ground to start using waterboarding, etc then you've dumped your morality full stop.
You cannot have it both ways... only tyrants try that and they fail..
Übergeek 바둑이: I know. police are prosecuted for over using violence and prosecuted and sent to jail.
If a criminal hurts someone they are sent to jail. I've never heard of someone being above the law.. even God is bound (or so they say) by the laws of physical science as they are bound from the moment of creation when all that is was decided to be.
Now if God has to obey the laws, I can see no exception!!
And it appears that the CIA were no longer considered a trustworthy source of intelligence. A total lack of trust in intelligence!!
So.. that made those high up afraid.. they then used that fear to justify torture. And because a certain amount of programming involving "us and them" was inbred into the American political system it created an ability to say "them".
And it appears that the CIA were no longer considered a trustworthy source of intelligence. A total lack of trust in intelligence!!
So.. that made those high up afraid.. they then used that fear to justify torture. And because a certain amount of programming involving "us and them" was inbred into the American political system it created an ability to say "them".
Subject: Re:That would in part require me to betray a trust.
Czuch: Well if your self justified, justify yourself. Others have been capable and have one won the fight without breaking the principles that they are fighting for.
So.. tell me. Why can't America?
You've signed all the conventions, taking part and pursued war criminals and tried them without all this 'torture' business, and then much bigger criminals then you have now for much of the same things that you now justify..
... So when did someone decide the American spirit has become so weak that it needs to behave as it once said was so wrong??
Czuch: You know your intel guys are taught to not give up info. Such training includes waterboarding simulation to make it so they don't give up info. That's how your guys who used it knew how to use it.
Czuch: Models don't work Czuch... they are based on a fixed unmoving world. As you know.. we are in orbit. And being subjective.. the laws of gravity change perspective in as much that time is distorted.
You know your GPS is reliant on constant daily updates to the clocks on the satellites due to the difference in time from living in 1G and zero G.
And as one political commentator said. So much can be dependent on little things, like whether somone is having a bad day or not. And us being humans.. can you predict accurately how someone will react?
Subject: Re:That would in part require me to betray a trust.
Artful Dodger: Nope, I answered. And if you had read up on why waterboarding was used (as I said .. due to a lack of trust in intelligence) you'd have my reply easily from my answers.
And Art.. There are times in your life when you cannot break trust. The Official Secrets Act (OSA) is one of them.. being a lawyer is another case, etc. I made a sincere promise and I intend to keep it!!!
But in respect, that is beside the point.
You want more clue's (I'm gonna make you stretch your grey stuff) ... Pan roams and that's all you get.
And Übergeek 바둑이 got the main point and the point you all seem to miss. It's a slippery slope when you've broken the moral ground you base your activities on.
If the rules of the Geneva Convention don't apply to all by certain US 'models' created to deal with a lack in trust of intelligence.... Then who gets to decide what is a correct interpretation of the law needed due to lack of trust in intelligence??
(hide) If you need to find an older message from the selected user, click on his Profile and use the "show this user messages" link at the page top. (konec) (show all tips)