Czuch Chuckers, I really like a baked potato bar. Bake up the taters then put out any and all of the toppings you like...diced ham, diced turkey, chili, different cheeses, diced green onions, sour cream, butter, ranch dressing, herbs, broccoli, diced bacon, etc.
If you use smaller potatoes, you can have more than one and get a bigger variety of toppings. It goes good with a side salad of some sort and maybe a side of assorted fruits.
Or were you looking for more of a "Romantic" dinner?