Username: Passwort:
Neue User - Registrierung
Moderator: Vikings 
 Politics

Forum for discussing local and world politics and issues. All views are welcomed. Let your opinions be heard on current news and politics.


All standard guidelines apply to this board, No Flaming, No Taunting, No Foul Language,No sexual innuendos,etc..

As politics can be a volatile subject, please consider how you would feel if your comment were directed toward yourself.

Any post deemed to be in violation of guidelines will be deleted or edited without warning or notification. Any continued misbehavior will result in a ban or hidden status, so please play nice!!!


*"Moderators are here for a reason. If a moderator (or Global Moderator or Fencer) requests that a discussion on a certain subject to cease - for whatever reason - please respect these wishes. Failure to do so may result in being hidden, or banned."


Nachrichten pro Seite:
Liste der Diskussionsforen
Es ist Dir nicht erlaubt, Nachrichten in diesem Forum zu schreiben. Man muss dazu mindestens den Mitgliedsrang Brain Bauer (Pawn) haben!
Modus: Jeder kann schreiben
In Postings suchen:  

18. Juli 2009, 07:22:54
Übergeek 바둑이 
Thema: Re:
GTCharlie:

Perhaps what I am getting at is that war crimes have become mired in moral and legal relativism. Milosevic was a war criminal of the worst kind and what he did is heinous and inexcusable.

The question is, if waterboarding was a war crime during WW II, did it stop being a war crime during the War on Terror? Japanese soldiers were sent to prison for waterboarding American POWs. Somehow in all the legal wrangling of the Bush administration the Patriot Act made it acceptable.

At the same time, we have done nothing to stop the Russians or the Chinese from oppressing their Moslem minorities. We have turned a blind eye to it because atrocities committed during the war in Iraq were swept under the carpet.

The Abu Graib scandal is merely the tip of the iceberg and most of the photographs were never seen by the public because of censorship. Iraq is no better than Vietnam was. I ask, does anyone know how many people have been killed in Iraq? Does anyone care? How many people must be killed before a war becomes a crime?

We have seen war planes bomb Iraq and sat there as if it were mere entertainment. Those nice fireworks on CNN do not show human death in real terms. The number of dead in Iraq is certainly a lot more than there were during the Balkan wars. The Coalition of the Willing has dispatched a lot more people to their death than Milosevic ever did. So, are we really better than he was?

18. Juli 2009, 07:43:22
Papa Zoom 
Thema: Re:
Übergeek 바둑이: It's odd that there is so much talk about water boarding even though it's only been used on the hardest of terrorists and only when the situation was somewhat desperate. And only three times and none since 2003. It seems to me that a great deal of though and care went into the use of this technique. It wasn't used as a matter of routine.

As for Iraq: I am troubled at the loss of life. Whenever civilians die it's sad. To be fair, the US does not blindly bomb. The US does not target civilians and is not careless when going after military targets.

When mistakes happen, it does not reflect the totality of the US armed forces. Most positive stories are never told. Only those that will help get ratings make it to prime time.

In hind sight, going into Iraq does seem to have been a mistake. With the exception that Saddam was a murderer of his own people, he wasn't more of a threat than most. But the once the US entered Iraq and was involved in the think of it, chatting about shoulds and shouldn'ts seem moot. Where do we go from here.

The US gets demonized too often. Even the current president apologizes for the US. Never mind the years of money and blood that this noble country has offered the world since it's inception.

I think that the best that can come of any of this fight against terrorism is to ask what we have learned and where do we go from here.

Time will tell if Iraq was fully a mistake. But lets be fair: many positive things came about because the US stood up to a tyrant.

18. Juli 2009, 14:25:18
Mort 
Thema: Re:But lets be fair: many positive things came about because the US stood up to a tyrant.
Artful Dodger: Hopefully yes. Hopefully it'll end the use of tyrants and the like by other country's, as those who would use 'evil' people will realise that it will end up biting you in the butt later.

eg... Iran is so annoyed with the west due it's people being killed by WMD supplied by the west. Now that mess is haunting the world and will for many years.

This is not 'demonising' but being honest of the results of actions that were flawed and irresponsible.

18. Juli 2009, 16:00:20
Czuch 
Thema: Re:But lets be fair: many positive things came about because the US stood up to a tyrant.
(V): Where do you stand on the issue of Iran, and giving them help producing nuclear materials?

18. Juli 2009, 15:50:50
Czuch 
Thema: Re:
Übergeek 바둑이: does anyone know how many people have been killed in Iraq?




Maybe you will tell us? I dont believe that the civilian toll dead at the direct hands of US military(coalition of the willing) is as high as you might believe.

18. Juli 2009, 15:54:25
Czuch 
Thema: Re:
Übergeek 바둑이: Iraq is no better than Vietnam was.




What exactly does that mean?


I have already given my first hand account from Vietnam, 2 decades later.... but a quick recap is that it was all good

18. Juli 2009, 15:55:24
Czuch 
Thema: Re:
Übergeek 바둑이: So, are we really better than he was?

Yes....

Datum und Zeit
Freunde Online
Abonnierte Foren
Vereine
Tip des Tages
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 Filip Rachunek, all rights reserved.
Zurück nach oben