Mélusine: One other thing, this may be a silly question, but are you giving the Fellowship a name before you click "Create"?
EDIT : Never mind, I see in your post below that you did name it. It couldn't have been the same name of a current fellowship could it? I'm grasping at straws here. LOL
(hide) If you want to find an opponent with similar playing skills to your own look in the Ratings page of the type of game you want and find a player with a similar BKR. (pauloaguia) (show all tips)