BrainKing - Diskutaj forumoj (Go)

Moderatoro: hexkid

Discuss about the game of Go or find new opponents.

Beginners:
This TUTORIAL will help you to learn the rules & basics.

More information about Go: senseis library
There is a fellowship dedicated to the game of Go.

Listo de diskutaj forumoj
Vi ne rajtas afiŝi mesaĝojn en ĉi tiu forumo. La minimuma necesa nivelo de la membreco por afiŝi mesaĝojn en ĉi tiu forumo estas Brain-Peono.

Moduso: Ĉiu rajtas sendi

1. Majo 2006, 00:00:53

Fwiffo

montri mesaĝojn de ĉi tiu uzanto | montri fadenon | ligilo

Hm I tried to give furbster 2 handicap stones in a teaching game, but surprisingly he got 3. It is usual to regard the placement of the handicap stones as blacks first move. Maybe it was noticed before on this board or in the Go fellowship. Have to look it up.

1. Majo 2006, 08:16:38

Fwiffo

montri mesaĝojn de ĉi tiu uzanto | montri fadenon | ligilo

Temo: Re:

Marfitalu: Yes probably. It is incorrect though:
0 handicap should be black starts the game, white has komi
1 handicap should be black starts the game with no komi for white
2 handicap should be black starts the game with two stones, no komi for white
etc.
I'll put it on my list :)

2. Majo 2006, 19:42:50

headius

montri mesaĝojn de ĉi tiu uzanto | montri fadenon | ligilo

Temo: Re:

Fwiffo: I think this is probably what you meant, but to clarify...when handicap stones are placed, every source I know of says white plays first. I think the exception is perhaps the handicap of "1" where black still plays first but white gets no komi.

If BK is allowing black to play first after placing handicap stones, that is certainly not correct.