BrainKing - Diskutaj forumoj (Backgammon)

Moderatoro: SueQ

Backgammon

Backgammon and variants.

Backgammon Links

Listo de diskutaj forumoj
Vi ne rajtas afiŝi mesaĝojn en ĉi tiu forumo. La minimuma necesa nivelo de la membreco por afiŝi mesaĝojn en ĉi tiu forumo estas Brain-Peono.

Moduso: Ĉiu rajtas sendi

6. Oktobro 2014, 20:07:27

coan.net

montri mesaĝojn de ĉi tiu uzanto | montri fadenon | ligilo

I disagree, and think it should have been 3 points.

Backgammon (3 points) - the opponent hasn't borne off any pieces and still has some pieces either on the bar or in the winner's home area (the six pipes where the winner bears off own pieces).

Since at that point, you COULD still have been sent back to the bar and/or your home area, then the max possible should be counted with a timeout in my opinion - so 3 points is what I would think a timeout should be worth.

6. Oktobro 2014, 22:05:04

playBunny

montri mesaĝojn de ĉi tiu uzanto | montri fadenon | ligilo

Temo: Re: Points given away by a timeout

coan.net: Since at that point, you COULD still have been sent back to the bar

Then shouldn't that apply to resignations as well?

On the other hand, if we're going by possibilities then it should be a draw (½ point each) because either player COULD win from that position.

7. Oktobro 2014, 07:35:54

Hrqls

montri mesaĝojn de ĉi tiu uzanto | montri fadenon | ligilo

Temo: Re: Points given away by a timeout

coan.net & playBunny: i agree: a resignation at this point would give my opponent 2 points, but my timeout gives him 3 point ? what is the difference between a timeout and a resignation ?

the only reason i can think of is that it is meant as a punishment against timing out ?