Nom d'utilisateur: Mot de passe:
Enregistrement d'un nouveau membre
Modérateur: hexkid 
 Go

Discuss about the game of Go or find new opponents.

Beginners:
This TUTORIAL will help you to learn the rules & basics.

More information about Go: senseis library
There is a fellowship dedicated to the game of Go.


Messages par page:
Liste des forums de discussions
Vous n'êtes pas autorisé de poster des messages dans ce forum. Le niveau d'adhésion minimal requis pour poster dans ce forum est Pion.
Mode: Tout le monde peut poster
Recherche dans les messages:  

2. Juin 2006, 22:38:20
headius 
Sujet: Komi fixes
Has there been any word on getting komi fixed? With a too-low komi (drastically low in 13x13 and 9x9 sizes) white is at a distinct disadvantage.

2. Juin 2006, 22:55:32
dameningen 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
headius: No. The normal is 6.5 in all these sizes if I had understand it right? At the current playing level of most of the people it is not problem, but of course more equal the better. I personally are not so sure which would be right komi.

2. Juin 2006, 23:02:44
hexkid 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
modifié par hexkid (2. Juin 2006, 23:05:27)
Salkkuman: Currently on BrainKing, komi is 5.5 for a 19x19 board, 4.5 for a 13x13 board and 3.5 for a 9x9 board.

At the current playing level of most of the people (me included, rating notwithstanding) maybe a komi of 0 (zero) would be nice :)

2. Juin 2006, 23:16:29
dameningen 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
hexkid: With normal I ment, outside of BK.

2. Juin 2006, 23:32:14
hexkid 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
Salkkuman: As with so many things in Go, the Sensei's page about Komi is inconclusive

4. Juin 2006, 23:22:25
headius 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
Salkkuman: I would vote for 6.5 for all sizes. For those who think komi should be larger or smaller for 13x13 or 9x9, consider this:

Yes, there are typically fewer points in 9x9 or 13x13...
...but the first move is also that much more important.

I believe most sources agree these two factors balance out so that komi should be the same on small boards.

In actuality, I would prefer a configurable komi, so we could specify it at game start, but I don't know how that would work with the current rating system. Fancier go sites are able to make games rated all the time, regardless of settings tweaks, but BK is limited in that regard. Perhaps only rated for default settings (komi 6.5, no handi)?

15. Juin 2006, 13:00:13
tbart 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
3.5 komi in 9x9 = really good for black

15. Juin 2006, 21:08:38
headius 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
tbart: That's why I try to avoid playing white on 13x13 or 9x9 on BK right now; they're heavily weighted toward black. We need komi fixed!

15. Juin 2006, 21:21:48
hexkid 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
headius: I think making komi a user-selectable value would be nice. Instead of getting handicap stones I could play a game with komi set to, for example, -83.5 :)

15. Juin 2006, 21:29:06
headius 
Sujet: Re: Komi fixes
hexkid: I'd be all over a user-selectable komi, so long as the standard rated games used correct komi to begin with.

Date et heure
Amis en ligne
Forums favoris
Associations
Astuce du jour
Copyright © 2002 - 2025 Filip Rachunek, tous droits réservés
Retour en haut