Having looked at the game i have to agree its an easy win for black. I have had many a talk with Ed and have found him to be a very nice person who has always been willing to answer any questions that i have had regarding computers,checkers,chess i regard him as a friend of good character, so i was surprised at the comments made I have made many friends on this and other sites i have a high regard for sportsmanship and value friendship so i find this affair upsetting im sure there must a reason for this .