(V):  Or a convenient way to avoid the question.  BTW, I figured you'd fail this little test.  The correct answer to my question would have pointed out that water boarding is a last course of interrogation and used only when other methods (such as your "secret" method) have failed.  That said, your answer to my question has to assume that those "secret" methods of yours would failed.  Because Jules, in point of fact, if those secret methods did actually work, then there would be no need to water board anyone.  It's only when other measures fail that water boarding is used. 

Now to the crux of the matter:  If all else fails you, and your family, friends, comrades' lives are at stake, and IF you have nothing left but to try the drastic step of water boarding, do you put other lives at risk for some nonsense such as higher ground or do you do the right thing and water board?

Me?  I'm a Jack Bower fan.  Some dude knows some intel that could bring harm to my family etc, I'm going right to well placed electrodes and gonna turn up the juice.