KewlGuy: It takes a little bit before the Fellowship list is updated - look on your profile, in the fellowship tab:

Hooters Saloon

I see that sort of thing all the time when a fellowship is first created - well not all the time, but often enough. Still say wait until tomorrow - and if still having issues, then send Fencer a message. There are processes which automatically run that fix many things - some of those processes only run ever few hours - or even once a day.