BrainKing - Diskusjonsforum (Backgammon)

Moderator: SueQ

Backgammon

Backgammon and variants.

Backgammon Links

Liste over diskusjonsforum
Du kan ikke skrive meldinger i dette forumet. For å kunne skrive her må ha et Brain Pawn medlemskap eller høyere.

Modus: Alle kan skrive

15. juli 2010, 19:59:09

alanback

vis innlegg fra denne brukeren | vis tråd | lenke

Emne: Re: Opening rolls for Brainking dice

Resher: Thanks for the analysis.

Of course, there's no reason to believe this phenomenon is limited to opening rolls. In general, it seems one should bear in mind the enhanced probability of duplicate or similar rolls in planning strategy.

Has anyone run a test on the distribution of single die rolls? One way that these observed deviations from the norm could arise would be if, say, the chance of rolling a 4 on a single die was significantly higher than it should be. Depending on the pseudo RNG that is used, this might be a simpler explanation than any theory involving pairs of dice.

16. juli 2010, 07:41:08

Thad

vis innlegg fra denne brukeren | vis tråd | lenke

Emne: Re: Opening rolls for Brainking dice

My guess would be that the random number generating function is fine. After all, think how hard it would be try and write a random number function but actually write something that produces the results we are seeing. The bad code would be obvious. Instead, I suspect that the code is not being called properly. Consider this outline for the code:

Whose turn? - Player 1
What do we need to do (accept double, accept draw, roll dice, etc.)
Roll dice
Show dice
Player 1 moves
Player 2's turn
What do we need to do (accept double, accept draw, roll dice, etc.)
Show dice
Player 2 moves

It would be pretty easy to bury a bug that could give us the results we are seeing with something like this.