Bruker navn: Passord:
Registrering av ny bruker
Moderator: rod03801 
 Feature requests

Do you miss something on BrainKing.com and would you like to see it here? Post your request into this board!
If there is a more specific board for the request, (i.e. game rule changes etc) then it should be posted and discussed on that specific board.

For further information about Feature Requests, please visit this link on the Brainking.Info site : http://brainking.info/archives/20-About-feature-requests.html


Meldinger pr side:
Liste over diskusjonsforum
Du kan ikke skrive meldinger i dette forumet. For å kunne skrive her må ha et Brain Knight medlemskap eller høyere.
Modus: Alle kan skrive
Søk i meldingene:  

3. desember 2003, 02:01:10
coan.net 
That is what I'm saying - the computer figures it out with many decimal points (but the rating on the screen - what you & i see - are without the decimal points)

So if it was a rated game, it is very possible that the rating did go up - just not enough to raise it another point.

.... and as you finish more games, the more "established" a rating will become - and the less it will fall/raise with wins & loses.

Since this is Feature request - Hey Fencer, any chance of possible in a persons profile, show the rating out to a couple of decimal points. I would be interested in them!

3. desember 2003, 02:22:41
california man 
Emne: Re: Scoring
Ratings here are a mystery, why should it go out to decimel points? A very simple way would be: scores within 200 pts, 6 pts. scores with in 400 points 4 pts and etc, So when a player makes a challege, they know what they will win or lose

3. desember 2003, 03:24:37
ChessCarpenter 
Emne: Re: Scoring
California man is right!! On USCF Live whenever you are playing an opponent you are prompted as to what your rating will be after a win, loss, or draw. ex. win +10, loss -2, draw +3. This way you will know if it is worth it to play your opponent.
The rating system we have here makes NO adjustments for draws what so ever!! No matter how high or low a person is rated against each other. That statement in itself tells us that the rating system we have is inaccurate. I don't know what rating sytem we use...but I know the Glickman sytem works pretty good! Is it possible to switch to this tried and true sytem Fencer?

3. desember 2003, 08:04:57
Fencer 
Emne: Re: Scoring
The rating system we have here makes NO adjustments for draws what so ever!!

This is not true. Ratings are calculated even for draws. When I have more time, I can review the algorhitm but I am sure it is correct, I've tested it many times.
However, if you know about a better one and want to help me, give me more details. Everything can be improved.

3. desember 2003, 16:14:41
grenv 
Emne: Re: Scoring
Fencer,
I would have to agree with the comment that drawn matches do not count. I have had quite a few drawn games. In many cases the difference in ratings was quite a lot (e.g 2000 vs 1300), in which case I would expect to increase the lower rating and decrease the higher rating. NEVER has this occurred. I suspect that there is a defect in the code somewhere causing this.

In addition I would suggest that winning a series 3-2 (which should score 0.6-0.4 where a draw is 0.5-0.5) should score less than winning 5-0. I haven't enough data to tell whether this is the case, but can you confirm that it should be? I suspect that the same piece of code would be used in this case and therefore it may not work either.

If necessary I volunteer to play someone in a game of something where our ratings are dissimilar and engineer a draw to test this hypothesis. Just invite me to a game and alert fencer so he can monitor the ratings.

Just trying to make sure it works!

3. desember 2003, 16:38:19
Jason 
Emne: Re: Scoring
im not sure to which games you refer too grenv but i know it works with checkers and five in line at least also tank battle works correctly ,other games i havent took any notice ;)

3. desember 2003, 17:09:48
grenv 
Emne: Re: Scoring
Well I'm referring to chess variations, but it would surprise me if some games worked and others didn't. Anyway a test would work, I have a high rating in some games and am willing to deliberately draw one game against a lower rated player at the risk of losing rating points while the ratings are monitored in order to test.

4. desember 2003, 10:38:38
kitti 
Emne: Re: Scoring
I'm also sure my rating has not changed after a draw even if there was a big difference in our ratings. This has happened several times, actually i don't think i've noticed my rating changing after a draw even once.

4. desember 2003, 17:16:39
grant 
Emne: Re: Scoring
draws have never changed my rating either, which is bloody annoying when you have to battle against a large rating difference in players

Dato og tid
Innloggede venner
Favorittforum
Laug
Dagens tips
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 Filip Rachunek, all rights reserved.
Tilbake til toppen