 |
|
 PenteNão pode escrever mensagens neste fórum. O nível mínimo de inscrição para o fazer neste fórum é Nível Peão. Modo de acesso: Qualquer um pode escrever
14. Maio 2003, 05:45:37 Assunto: Gary doesn't know fact from fiction Gary,
Get your facts straight! I did not, have not, and will not fall into any trap you set for me here on this discussion board. You said: "Thad - "Well, we haven't had a good disagreement or debate for a while, so I have to start one. :-) " To which I replied: "About draws...sorry Gary, I'm not going there." Meaning that I wasn't going to discuss the matter with you. I will however, discuss it with Dmitri, Walter, or anyone else, just not with you. To which Walter said: "Thad, why not go there? Gary even invited you to." And I told Walter the exact reasons why. Anyone can read them in my earlier post. Let's add another - Gary makes up his own 'facts'. You said: "You made these 2 EXTREME comparisons that affect MANY people and take MUCH time to playing just a FEW more moves (usually 1 to 5 moves) to break draws in Poof Pente that only affect 2 people " In fact, I did no such thing. Dmitri questioned why so many people against the idea that some people are going to win and some people are going to lose? He said he didn't see how breaking a tie in any way cheapens anything. Then I mentioned two situations, a soccer game, and the NHL. NEVER did I compare either to poof-pente. Then you said: "And then comparing a mom & pop turn-based site to a once in 5 years real-time pente championship as well as lunar ecplises to infrequent draws in Poof Pente." While I did, in fact mention those things, again, I NEVER compared them to pente. Then you said: "You might want to consider doing a little research into what the World Pente Federation is all about, what it will encompass, and how it will promote the game before you start calling it a 'bunch of guys'." Once again, I did not do what you claim I did. Reread my post. I NEVER SAID it was a just bunch of guys. I questioned if that was the case, but I also questioned if it was a bonified organization. By the way, I entered 'World Pente Federation' into Google, AltaVista, Yahoo!, & Lycos. Know how many references to the World Pente Federation they came up with? ZERO!! So you see, you did not get me 'hook, line, and sinker'. All you did was get egg all over your face for quoting me incorrectly, not once, not twice, but THREE TIMES! Debate that! 14. Maio 2003, 14:45:42 Assunto: Re: Gary doesn't know fact from fiction Thad-- you said "Meaning that I wasn't going to discuss the matter with you. I will however, discuss it with Dmitri, Walter, or anyone else, just not with you. "
Well, debate I shall. The top of draws came up while discussing PENTE. So unless your sports references were analogies to PENTE, WHY did you bring them up? it seems to me like you were using sports analogies to justify the ocurrence of draws in pente, on the basis that society is too hung up on declaring a winner. This is what I have to say about your sports references. Thre is something in Logic called the fallacy of weak analogy. but yours do not fall into that category, because they are too lousy to even qualify for that. They are a new category called "fallacy of appalingly inept analogies." wihch is to say, your sports analogies have nothing to do with anything. We are trying to talk about draws in pente here and you are strayingf so far off topic that you would need a telescope to see the topic. 14. Maio 2003, 22:09:51 Assunto: Re: Gary doesn't know fact from fiction Dmitri,
I think I will try to reply to your posts one at a time rather than in one big post. Hopefully, that will be a little clearer for all. With respect to my sports references, I was NOT trying to use analogies to sports as a way to justify draws in pente. I was only trying to make the point, in response to what you wrote, that ties, at times, are a good thing. You had said, "Why are so many people against the idea that some people are going to win and some people are going to lose? I don't asee how breaking a tie in any way cheapens anything.", and I wanted to point out that there is no need to break EVERY tie, not EVERY game needs to have a winner and a loser. THAT was my point. I was NOT trying to draw or imply any conclusions about poof-pente. Also, please don't accuse me of straying off topic by using sports analogies. When I posted them, I was replying to YOUR comments of: "I suppose having the world series, NBA finals, or Super Bowl be declared a tie wuold be acceptable to you?" And "remember the all star game lkast year in baseball?" Thad 14. Maio 2003, 14:51:03 Assunto: Re: Gary doesn't know fact from fiction Thad, you said : "Once again, I did not do what you claim I did. Reread my post. I NEVER SAID it was a just bunch of guys. I questioned if that was the case, but I also questioned if it was a bonified organization. "
PLEASE. it was clear that you were strongly implying that it is "just a bunch of guys," HENCE YOUR REPEATING IT 4 TIMEs!!!!!!!!! 14. Maio 2003, 22:32:58 Assunto: Re: Gary doesn't know fact from fiction Dmitri,
About my questioning if WPF was 'just a bunch of guys'. I meant no disrespect to you or anyone else involved with that organization other than Gary. At the time, He was the only person who I knew had anything to do with it. I apologize to you if you felt insulted by my comments there. That was never my intention. Gary has made mention time and time again about the WPF and it's goals and intentions. I felt that it was time for Gary to - I'm not quite sure how to phrase this - put up or shut up about WPF. I wanted Gary to get all fired up about showing me how WPF wasn't 'just a bunch of guys'. I wanted to paint him into a corner and FORCE him to show us that WPF really was something, or back down and admit it wasn't really anything at all. To my surprise, he did neither. Instead He made a post with the subject, "Thad, got ya, hook, line, & sinker! :-)" in which he claimed I fell right into his trap and that he "set [me] up BIG for that one". I still don't know what it is he 'set me up for'. But the bigger question is why would he do something like that? Hats off to Mark for stepping up and answering my questions about WPF. Thanks again, & sorry, Mark, if you were offended by what I said or how I said it. Why couldn't Gary have done that? Thad |
Data e hora
Amigos online
Fóruns favoritos
Clubes
Dica do dia
|
|
Copyright © 2002 - 2024 Filip Rachunek, todos os direitos reservados. Voltar para o topo |